Why eye color varies
Eye color varies due to the amount and distribution of melanin, a pigment that gives color to your skin, hair, and eyes, as well as genetic factors that determine how much melanin your body produces. The color of your eyes is largely controlled by genetic inheritance, with a complex interplay of multiple genes influencing the final color. The iris, the colored part of the eye, gets its color based on the concentration and distribution of melanin in the front layers of the iris.
The Role of Melanin in Eye Color:
Melanin is the pigment responsible for the color of your iris. The amount of melanin determines whether your eyes are brown, blue, green, hazel, or gray. Here's how it works:
High amounts of melanin: If your iris contains a high concentration of melanin, the eyes will appear darker—usually brown or black. The more melanin there is in the iris, the darker the eye color.
Low amounts of melanin: If your iris contains a small amount of melanin, the eyes will appear lighter—like blue, gray, or green. Less melanin allows light to scatter more in the iris, creating these lighter colors.
How Eye Color is Determined:
Eye color is primarily determined by genetic variations. While it used to be thought that a simple inheritance pattern controlled eye color—where brown was dominant over blue—it’s now understood that many genes are involved in determining eye color. The two main genes responsible for eye color are located on chromosome 15 and chromosome 19.
OCA2 Gene (Chromosome 15):
The OCA2 gene is the most significant gene that influences eye color. It produces a protein that helps control the amount of melanin present in the iris.
Variations in this gene can lead to less melanin being produced, which results in lighter eye colors like blue or green. Mutations in this gene can also cause conditions like albinism, where very little melanin is produced, leading to extremely light eye colors.
HERC2 Gene (Chromosome 15):
The HERC2 gene helps regulate the activity of the OCA2 gene. Certain variations in the HERC2 gene can reduce OCA2's ability to produce melanin, resulting in lighter eye colors.
In people with blue eyes, specific mutations in the HERC2 gene prevent the OCA2 gene from producing high levels of melanin.
Other Genes:
Additional genes (on chromosome 19 and elsewhere) contribute to the final eye color, influencing the shade and intensity of the color. These genes affect not just the amount of melanin but also the distribution of melanin across the iris.
Because of this complex genetic interplay, eye color can range from dark brown to light blue, with many variations in between, including green, hazel, and gray.
Why Eye Colors Vary:
Brown Eyes:
Brown is the most common eye color worldwide. It occurs when the iris contains a high concentration of melanin, giving it a darker hue. People with brown eyes have more melanin in the front layer of their iris, which absorbs more light, making their eyes appear darker.
Brown eyes are considered dominant in terms of genetic inheritance, meaning that if one parent has brown eyes, there is a higher likelihood that their children will have brown eyes.
Blue Eyes:
Blue eyes occur when there is very little melanin in the front layer of the iris. The blue color comes from Rayleigh scattering, the same phenomenon that makes the sky appear blue. In blue eyes, light entering the iris scatters and reflects back as blue.
Blue eyes are a recessive trait, meaning two copies of the gene for low melanin are typically needed for blue eyes to occur. People with blue eyes often share a common ancestor who lived around 6,000–10,000 years ago, when the gene mutation responsible for blue eyes first appeared.
Green Eyes:
Green eyes have slightly more melanin than blue eyes but much less than brown eyes. The green color results from a combination of light brown or amber pigmentation with the Rayleigh scattering of light through the low melanin content in the iris.
Green is one of the rarest eye colors, occurring in only about 2% of the world’s population.
Hazel Eyes:
Hazel eyes are a mix of brown and green pigments. They have more melanin than green or blue eyes, but the melanin is not evenly distributed. Hazel eyes can appear to change color in different lighting conditions due to varying amounts of melanin in different parts of the iris.
Gray Eyes:
Gray eyes are similar to blue eyes but have even less melanin. In gray eyes, the lack of melanin causes the stroma (the front part of the iris) to scatter light differently, giving the eyes a grayish hue.
Like blue eyes, gray eyes result from the scattering of light in the iris and are among the rarest eye colors.
Amber Eyes:
Amber eyes are characterized by a golden or coppery hue. This is due to the presence of pheomelanin, a yellowish pigment, in the iris. Amber eyes have a unique warm color that is not common and tends to stand out.
Genetics of Eye Color:
Eye color is influenced by polygenic inheritance, meaning it is controlled by multiple genes rather than just one. While earlier models of eye color inheritance suggested a simple dominant-recessive pattern (brown being dominant over blue), the reality is more complex.
Brown Eye Color: Generally results from dominant alleles (versions of a gene) that promote high melanin production.
Blue Eye Color: Typically results from recessive alleles that limit melanin production.
Other Colors: Intermediate eye colors, like hazel or green, result from varying amounts of melanin, which are controlled by a more complex interaction of multiple genes.
Can Eye Color Change?
In most people, eye color is determined at birth, but the final color may not be fully established until a child is about 1–3 years old. This is because melanin production in the iris increases after birth. Babies are often born with blue or gray eyes, which may darken as melanin production increases in the first few years of life.
Aging: Eye color can change slightly with age, especially in people with lighter-colored eyes. As melanin production decreases over time, some individuals may notice their eye color becoming lighter.
Health Conditions: Certain diseases, injuries, or medications can also cause changes in eye color, but this is relatively rare.
Conclusion:
Eye color is determined by genetics, specifically the amount and distribution of melanin in the iris. People with more melanin have brown or dark eyes, while those with less melanin have lighter eyes (blue, green, gray, or hazel). Eye color inheritance is complex, involving multiple genes, and although brown eyes are the most common, variations in genetic combinations lead to a wide range of eye colors across the population.
References
What causes Heterochromia and what should I do about it? – Urgent Care Center of Arlington, VA. https://urgentcarearlingtonva.com/what-causes-heterochromia-and-what-should-i-do-about-it/
Patel, D. (2015). Skin pigmentation. International Journal of Child Health and Human Development, 8(1), 21-28.
Cat Eye Colors - Color List And Fun Facts - Cat Product Guide. https://catproductguide.com/cat-eye-colors/
What Color Eyes Do Black People Have? Brown Eye!. https://colorvisit.com/what-color-eyes-do-black-people-have/
Glacier Ice Features - Glaciers (U.S. National Park Service). https://www.nps.gov/subjects/glaciers/glacier-ice-features.htm
Weinreb, S. (1955). Homalozoon vermiculare(Stokes): II. Parapharyngeal Granules and Trichites*. The Journal of Protozoology. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1550-7408.1955.tb02401.x
Solotica Hidrocor Mel | Green Color Contact Lenses | Official Store. https://www.solotica.com/hidrocor-mel
Hazel Eyes: Separating Fact from Fiction. https://ca.zennioptical.com/blog/hazel-eyes-separating-fact-from-fiction/
When Do Babies' Eye Colors Change? Understanding the Fascinating Journey of Eye Color Development – Better Ask Me. https://betteraskme.com/blogs/science/when-do-babies-eye-colors-change-understanding-the-fascinating-journey-of-eye-color-development
What Color Are Bruno Mars' Eyes? - Discount Lenses. https://discount-lenses.com/what-color-are-bruno-mars-eyes/